Some OK vocal harmonies and a couple of nice guitar chords do not an album make and Long Island’s latest band of boys to gather together with eyes fixed on the Big Prize of indie stardom and life whiled away in the back of a van on the back roads and in the back rooms of the American indie wasteland barely make it to the chorus of album opener “All the Days” before one considers that these guys may have been better off staying in the rehearsal room just a little longer. Influenced the guys that Todd Rundgren begat when he begat Ben Folds and the 15 minute famous New Radicals, Aeroplane Pageant isn’t a bad band per se, it’s just not much above a mediocre one. - Jedd Beaudoin (2007, The Daily Copper)